Paperback Edition
Paperback
200 pages
$19.95
Choose vendor to order paperback edition
BrownWalker Press
Amazon.com
Barnes & Noble
Harvard Book Store
Return policy
PDF eBook
Entire PDF eBook
870k
$17
Get instant access to an entire eBook
Buy PDF Password
Download Complete PDF
eBook editions
The Spectacle of the Growth of Knowledge and Swift's Satires on Science
by Beat Affentranger


Publisher: | Dissertation |
Pub date: | 2000 |
Pages: | 200 |
ISBN-10: | 1581120680 |
ISBN-13: | 9781581120684 |
Categories: | Communications and the Arts Literary Criticism Social Science |
Abstract
This is a revisionist study of seventeenth- and eighteenth-century satires on science with an emphasis on the writings of Jonathan Swift and, to a lesser degree, Samuel Butler and other satirists. To say, as some literary commentators do, that the satirists attacked only pseudo-scientists who failed to employ the empirical method properly is to beg a crucial question: how could the satirists possibly have distinguished the genuine scientist from the crank? By a failsafe set of Baconian principles perhaps? No, the matter is more complicated. I read the satiric literature on early modern science against a totally different understanding of what science is, how it came into being, and how it developed.Satire has a decided advantage over scientific discourse. It can rely on common sense; scientific discourse often cannot. There is always a counter-intuitive element in the genuinely new. New knowledge is in some ways always at odds with received assumptions of what is possible, reasonable, or probable. Satire on science, I suggest, can be seen as a systematic exploitation of that gap of plausibility. Natural philosophers of the late seventeenth- and early eighteenth-century were keenly aware of their discursive disadvantage and at times even hesitated to publish their material. They feared the satirists and the wits, who they knew would find it easy to debunk their work on commonsense grounds. But commonsense and laughter are unreliable yardsticks for measuring scientific merit. Ironically, the satirists and the natural philosophers shared some of the most fundamental epistemological assumptions of early English empiricism, for instance, the stereotypical Baconian assumption that knowledge about nature would come to us unambiguously once the mind was freed from preconception and bias. It is an assumption about scientific method that is decidedly hostile towards speculative hypothesising. Indeed, the motto of the day was not bold speculation and learning from error, but avoiding error at all costs. Yet in practice, error (or what appeared to be erroneous) was of course frequent; for science is an essentially speculative enterprise. Natural philosophers of the early modern period, however, were embarrassed by their failures and tried to explain them away. The satirists, on the other hand, could prey on these mistakes and conclude that the work of the natural philosophers was purely speculative. The reason for this rigid, anti-speculative epistemological stance, I argue, was a religious one, having to do with the conception of nature as a divine book that could be read like Scripture.
This conflation of the epistemological and the theological is especially obvious in Swift. In both his satirical and non-satirical writings, he is obsessed with proposing proper standards of interpretation, and with criticising those whom he thought had corrupted these standards. Dissenters and religious enthusiasts are taken to task for their misreading of Scripture, for their corrupt religious doctrine which they erroneously claim to be based on Scripture and reason. The natural philosophers are accused of some similar hermeneutic sin; only, they have committed their interpretive transgressions against the proper interpretive standard of the book of nature. Where the natural philosophers claim to have found a new, more accurate way of reading the book of nature, Swift, I argue, sees only mis-readings. Rhetorically, Swift's satires on religious dissent perpetuate the typically Tory High-Church insinuation of sectarian and heretical sexual promiscuity. In his satires on science, Swift makes the same insinuation with respect to natural philosophers, most vividly so in A Tale of a Tub and the flying island of Laputa. The study concludes with a fresh look at Swift's rational horses in part four of Gulliver's Travels.
Paperback Edition
Paperback
200 pages
$19.95
Choose vendor to order paperback edition
BrownWalker Press
Amazon.com
Barnes & Noble
Harvard Book Store
Return policy
PDF eBook
Entire PDF eBook
870k
$17
Get instant access to an entire eBook
Buy PDF Password
Download Complete PDF
eBook editions
Share this book
Relevant events
OCT
3
SSCONFERENCE
2nd International Conference on Social Sciences
The 2nd International Conference on Social Sciences will take place on the 03-05 of October in one of the most iconic cities in the world – Milan, Italy. Milan holds immense historical, cultural, and philosophical signific...
2nd International Conference on Social Sciences
The 2nd International Conference on Social Sciences will take place on the 03-05 of October in one of the most iconic cities in the world – Milan, ...
2nd International Conference on Social Sciences
The 2nd International Conference on Social Sciences will take place on th...
2nd International Conference on Social Sciences
The 2nd International Conference on Social Scien...
03 - 05 Oct 2025
Milan, Italy
OCT
17
3SCONF 2025
8th World Conference on Social Sciences Studies
🌍 Why Attend 3SCONF 2025?
8th World Conference on Social Sciences Studies
📍 Lyon, France | 📅 17–19 October 2025
Join leading voices in social sciences at 3SCONF 2025—a dynamic international forum set in the histo...
8th World Conference on Social Sciences Studies
🌍 Why Attend 3SCONF 2025?
8th World Conference on Social Sciences Studies
📍 Lyon, France | 📅 17–19 October 2025
Join leading voices in so...
8th World Conference on Social Sciences Studies
🌍 Why Attend 3SCONF 2025?
8th World Conference on Social Sciences Stu...
8th World Conference on Social Sciences Studies
🌍 Why Attend 3SCONF 2025?
8th World Conferen...
17 - 19 Oct 2025
Lyon, France
OCT
24
RSCONF
3rd Global Conference on Research in Social Sciences (RSCONF)
Conference Overview
The 3rd Global Conference on Research in Social Sciences (RSCONF) will be held in Oxford, UK, from 24-26 October 2025. This global event brings together top scholars and professionals to explore innova...
3rd Global Conference on Research in Social Sciences (RSCONF)
Conference Overview
The 3rd Global Conference on Research in Social Sciences (RSCONF) will be held in Oxford, UK, from 24-26 October 2025. This gl...
3rd Global Conference on Research in Social Sciences (RSCONF)
Conference Overview
The 3rd Global Conference on Research in Social Scie...
3rd Global Conference on Research in Social Sciences (RSCONF)
Conference Overview
The 3rd Global Conference o...
24 - 26 Oct 2025
Oxford, United Kingdom
OCT
24
The 5th Int’l Conference on Human Resource and Enterprise Management(CHREM 2025)
The 5th Int’l Conference on Human Resource and Enterprise Management(CHREM 2025)
Oct. 24-26, 2025 Xiamen, China
Website:https://www.academicx.org/CHREM/2025/
Website:Oct. 24-26, 2025
Venue:Xiamen, China
Email:edit...
The 5th Int’l Conference on Human Resource and Enterprise Management(CHREM 2025)
The 5th Int’l Conference on Human Resource and Enterprise Management(CHREM 2025)
Oct. 24-26, 2025 Xiamen, China
Website:https://www.academicx...
The 5th Int’l Conference on Human Resource and Enterprise Management(CHREM 2025)
The 5th Int’l Conference on Human Resource and Enterprise Management(CHRE...
The 5th Int’l Conference on Human Resource and Enterprise Management(CHREM 2025)
The 5th Int’l Conference on Human Resource and E...
24 - 26 Oct 2025
Xiamen, China, China
NOV
7
RSSCONF
10th International Conference on Research in Social Sciences
The 10th International Conference on Research in Social Sciences is a leading conference in politics, humanities, communications, law, education, and other areas of social sciences. Beautiful Bangkok, Thailand will be the ...
10th International Conference on Research in Social Sciences
The 10th International Conference on Research in Social Sciences is a leading conference in politics, humanities, communications, law, education, a...
10th International Conference on Research in Social Sciences
The 10th International Conference on Research in Social Sciences is a lea...
10th International Conference on Research in Social Sciences
The 10th International Conference on Research in...
07 - 09 Nov 2025
Bangkok, Thailand
NOV
21
SOCIALSCIENCES
9th World Conference on Research in Social Sciences (Socialsciencesconf)
Join the 9th World Conference on Research in Social Sciences!
📅 21 – 23 November 2025
📍 Copenhagen, Denmark
Be part of a dynamic gathering of scholars, researchers, and professionals from around the world at one of ...
9th World Conference on Research in Social Sciences (Socialsciencesconf)
Join the 9th World Conference on Research in Social Sciences!
📅 21 – 23 November 2025
📍 Copenhagen, Denmark
Be part of a dynamic gathering o...
9th World Conference on Research in Social Sciences (Socialsciencesconf)
Join the 9th World Conference on Research in Social Sciences!
📅 21 – 23...
9th World Conference on Research in Social Sciences (Socialsciencesconf)
Join the 9th World Conference on Research in Soc...
21 - 23 Nov 2025
Copenhagen, Denmark
NOV
28
ICMHS
10th International Conference on Modern Approaches in Humanities and Social Sciences (ICMHS)
Why Attend ICMHS 2025?
8th World Conference on Social Sciences Studies
📍 Vienna, Austria | 📅 28-30 November 2025
Join leading voices in social sciences at ICMHS, a dynamic international forum set in the Vienna. Th...
10th International Conference on Modern Approaches in Humanities and Social Sciences (ICMHS)
Why Attend ICMHS 2025?
8th World Conference on Social Sciences Studies
📍 Vienna, Austria | 📅 28-30 November 2025
Join leading voices in so...
10th International Conference on Modern Approaches in Humanities and Social Sciences (ICMHS)
Why Attend ICMHS 2025?
8th World Conference on Social Sciences Studies...
10th International Conference on Modern Approaches in Humanities and Social Sciences (ICMHS)
Why Attend ICMHS 2025?
8th World Conference o...
28 - 30 Nov 2025
Vienna, Austria
DEC
5
ICS21
The 10th International Conference on Social Sciences in the 21st Century
The 10th International Conference on Social Sciences in the 21st Century (ICS21) is set to take place in the historic city of Dublin, Ireland, from December 05 to 07, 2025. As one of the most anticipated social sciences co...
The 10th International Conference on Social Sciences in the 21st Century
The 10th International Conference on Social Sciences in the 21st Century (ICS21) is set to take place in the historic city of Dublin, Ireland, from...
The 10th International Conference on Social Sciences in the 21st Century
The 10th International Conference on Social Sciences in the 21st Century ...
The 10th International Conference on Social Sciences in the 21st Century
The 10th International Conference on Social Scie...
05 - 07 Dec 2025
Dublin, Ireland
DEC
6
ICRBS 2025
13th International Conference on Research in Behavioral and Social Sciences
ICRBS returns for its 13th edition, reaffirming its status as a premier event in behavioral and social sciences. Over the past decade, it has evolved into a pivotal conference for professionals in these fields, aiming to e...
13th International Conference on Research in Behavioral and Social Sciences
ICRBS returns for its 13th edition, reaffirming its status as a premier event in behavioral and social sciences. Over the past decade, it has evolv...
13th International Conference on Research in Behavioral and Social Sciences
ICRBS returns for its 13th edition, reaffirming its status as a premier e...
13th International Conference on Research in Behavioral and Social Sciences
ICRBS returns for its 13th edition, reaffirming ...
06 - 06 Dec 2025
Vienna, Austria
DEC
12
WORLDCMC
6th World Conference on Media and Communication
The 6th edition of the World Conference on Media and Communication will be bringing together members of academia from around the world for three days of intense learning, discussions, and networking.
The success of the ...
6th World Conference on Media and Communication
The 6th edition of the World Conference on Media and Communication will be bringing together members of academia from around the world for three da...
6th World Conference on Media and Communication
The 6th edition of the World Conference on Media and Communication will b...
6th World Conference on Media and Communication
The 6th edition of the World Conference on Media...
12 - 14 Dec 2025
Cambridge, United Kingdom