Paperback Edition
Paperback
264 pages
$25.95
Choose vendor to order paperback edition
BrownWalker Press Amazon.com Barnes & Noble Harvard Book Store Return policy
PDF eBook
Sample Preview
Size 61k
Free
Download a sample of the first 25 pages
Download Preview

Entire PDF eBook
423k
$17
Get instant access to an entire eBook
Buy PDF Password Download Complete PDF
eBook editions

Pragmatism and Human Genetic Engineering

by Glenn E. McGee
small book icon  Paperback   small ebook icon   eBook PDF
Publisher:  Dissertation
Pub date:  1998
Pages:  264
ISBN-10:  1581120206
ISBN-13:  9781581120202
Categories:  Biological Sciences  Science  Philosophy

Abstract

William James and John Dewey insisted that pragmatic philosophy finds meaning in its struggle to deal with emergent social problems. Ironically, few have attempted to use pragmatism to articulate methods for ameliorating social difficulties. This dissertation attempts to do just that by putting James' and Dewey's philosophy to work on the moral and scientific problems associated with genetic engineering and the Human Genome Project. The intention is to demonstrate the usefulness of a pragmatic approach to applied ethics and philosophy of biology.

The work of proponents and critics of genetic engineering is examined, including LeRoy Hood, Hans Jonas, Leon Kass, Robert Nozick, Jeremy Rifkin, Robyn Rowland, and Paul Ramsey. It is concluded that excessive optimism and pessimism about genetic engineering rests primarily on two errors. The first, basic to the Genome Project, is that organisms are essentially determined by their genes, and that the expression of genes is identical across human populations. I draw both on Richard Lewontin and on Dewey's Logic: The Theory of Inquiry to argue that the formation of human natures is instead the result of a fluid and interpenetrative relationship between hereditary information and varying environmental conditions. Organisms express DNA in different ways under different circumstances, and DNA itself is modified by exposure to mutagens.

The second error prevalent in the literature is the belief that genetic engineering is uniquely problematic, requiring a new kind of ethics. To counter the received view, I detail numerous cases in the history of biology and philosophy in which humans have faced moral choices similar to those present in the new genetics. In addition, I resituate new reproductive decisions in the context of everyday problems faced by parents in society, arguing that the hopes and choices of parents provide a matrix within which genetic decisions can be made. I caution against the expansion of genetic diagnosis, and detail some of the greatest real dangers present in positive genetic engineering. Finally, I suggest pragmatic alternatives to positive genetic engineering, including education and health care reform.





Paperback Edition
Paperback
264 pages
$25.95
Choose vendor to order paperback edition
BrownWalker Press Amazon.com Barnes & Noble Harvard Book Store Return policy
PDF eBook
Sample Preview
Size 61k
Free
Download a sample of the first 25 pages
Download Preview

Entire PDF eBook
423k
$17
Get instant access to an entire eBook
Buy PDF Password Download Complete PDF
eBook editions
Share this book



Relevant events
JUN
23
SOFE2025
Symposium on Fusion Engineering 2025 Hosted by the MIT Plasma Science & Fusion Center at MIT's campus in Cambridge, MA We at th...
23 - 26 Jun 2025
Cambridge, United States
DEC
5
WSEAAE-2024
World Summit and Expo on Aerospace and Aeronautical Engineering (WSEAAE-2024) Welcome to the World Summit and Expo on Aerospace and Aeronautical Engineering (WSEAAE-2024) ...
05 - 07 Dec 2024
Prague, Czech Republic
DEC
7
"Memory and Trauma" International Conference Memory and trauma are two deeply interconnected phenomena that have captivated the attention ...
07 - 08 Dec 2024
London/Online, United Kingdom
DEC
15
CFP BROLLY
CfP (December 15, 2024): BROLLY. Journal of Social Sciences (London, UK) CfP: BROLLY. Journal of Social Sciences (London, UK) Vol. 5, No. 3, December 2024 (Genera...
15 - 30 Dec 2024
Online Event | United Kingdom
DEC
20
RSSCONF
9th International Conference on Research in Social Sciences The 9th International Conference on Research in Social Sciences is a leading conference in po...
20 - 22 Dec 2024
Berlin, Germany
FEB
13
International Meet & Expo on Chemical Engineering and Catalysis We are elated to announce the much-anticipated International Meet on Chemical Engineering and...
13 - 15 Feb 2025
Dubai, United Arab Emirates
FEB
21
SOCIALSCINECES
The 8th World Conference on Research in Social Sciences (Socialscinecesconf) The 8th World Conference on Research in Social Sciences will gather academics from around the...
21 - 23 Feb 2025
Milan, Italy
FEB
21
ICCCP 2025
2025 14th International Conference on Chemistry and Chemical Process (ICCCP 2025) Publication: The accepted and registered papers will be published into International Journal...
21 - 24 Feb 2025
Okinawa, Japan
MAR
7
ICARSH
9th International Conference on Advanced Research in Social Sciences and Humanities Having successfully launched the eighth edition of the ICARSH conference, we are happy to ann...
07 - 09 Mar 2025
Vienna, Austria
MAR
13
AGRICONF
5th Global Conference on Agriculture The 5th Global Conference on Agriculture, scheduled for March 13-15, 2025, in Berlin, Germany...
13 - 15 Mar 2025
Berlin, Germany